The Pizzeria of Bay Shore
Popular Dishes
Fresh mozzarella cheese | red sauce | parmesan cheese | olive oil crust
$27.95
Fresh mozzarella | olive oil crust | parmesan cheese
$27.95
Fresh mozzarella | red sauce | olive oil | sicilian crust
$27.95
Cup & char pepperoni | mike's hot honey drizzle | basil | sicilian crust
$28.95
Chicken, eggplant, meatball or shrimp w/ red sauce or vodka sauce
$23.95
Menu for The Pizzeria of Bay Shore
round pies
the bay shore piefresh mozzarella cheese | red sauce | parmesan cheese | olive oil crust | $27.95 |
our margheritafresh mozzarella | olive oil crust | parmesan cheese | $27.95 |
vodka margheritafresh mozzarella cheese | vodka sauce | parmesan cheese | olive oil crust | $27.95 |
tri-fectafresh mozzarella cheese | vodka sauce | red sauce | pesto | olive oil crust | $27.95 |
bar piered sauce | light mozzarella cheese | burrata | hot honey | olive oil crust | $27.95 |
bruschettabalsamic infused crust | fresh bruschetta | burrata cheese | glaze | $28.95 |
chicken bacon ranchbreaded chicken | crispy bacon | mozzarella | cheddar | ranch dressing | $29.95 |
buffalo chickenmarinated buffalo chicken | mozzarella | buffalo sauce | $29.95 |
gluten free personal piegluten free & dairy free crust | $15.95 |
square pies
upside downfresh mozzarella | red sauce | olive oil | sicilian crust | $27.95 |
the honey pepcup & char pepperoni | mike's hot honey drizzle | basil | sicilian crust | $28.95 |
crumbling vodkafresh mozzarella | vodka sauce | crumbled spicy sausage | grandma crust | $28.95 |
meatball burratahomemade meatballs | marinara | burrata cheese | basil | parmesan cheese | $28.95 |
whitericotta | marscarpone | mozzarella | white truffle oil | $27.95 |
thai chili chickenmarinated thai chili chicken | mozzarella | thai chili sauce | $29.95 |
detroitfour cheese crispy crust | mozzarella center | vodka w/pepperoni or marinara | $24.95 |
dinner
parmigianachicken, eggplant, meatball or shrimp w/ red sauce or vodka sauce | $23.95 |
chicken franceseegg battered chicken in a white wine lemon butter sauce | $23.95 |
the pizzeria chickenchicken cutlet w/ fresh mozz, arugula, cherry tomato & balsamic glaze | $23.95 |
pasta
the mezzi rig.mini rigatoni | seasoned vodka sauce | mozzarella cheese | $18.95 |
beggars' purses5 cheese pouches | vodka sauce | crumbled sausage | $18.95 |
broccoli rabeorecchiette | crumbled sausage | garlic & oil | $18.95 |
penna alla vodka | $18.95 |
pasta with meatballs | $16.95 |
baked ziti | - |
salads
the saladmixed field greens, honey crisp apples, cherry tomatoes, croutons, candied pecans, parmesan crisps & cheddar cheese | $14.95 |
housemixed field greens, cherry tomatoes, red onion, cucumbers, freshly made croutons & mozzarella cheese | $12.95 |
caesarromaine, shaved parmesan cheese, parmesan crisps & homemade croutons | $13.95 |
fresh focaccia bread creations
prosciuttoprosciutto, fresh mozzarella, tomato, basil & olive oil | $12.95 |
pesto grilled chickengrilled chicken, pesto, fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers | $12.95 |
capreseheirloom tomato, fresh mozzarella, basil & olive oil | $10.95 |
small bites
garlic knots | $0.60 |
buffalo knots | $0.60 |
rice ball | $1.95 |
pepperoni or broccoli pinwheel | $4.25 |
garlic bread with mozzarella | $5.95 |
grilled chicken caesar wrap | $9.95 |
calzone (baked or fried) | $8.95 |
chicken roll | $9.95 |
mozzarella sticks | $10.95 |
fried ravioli | $10.95 |
meatballs | $10.95 |
buffalo wings | $14.95 |
heros & sandwiches
parmigiana herochicken, eggplant, meatball or shrimp (marinara or vodka sauce) | $12.95 |
the herochicken or meatball, marinara, burrata, fresh basil, shaved parmesan | $14.95 |
pizza
regular | $19.95 |
sicilian | $22.95 |
grandma | $22.95 |
dessert
zeppole | $2.50 |
mini cannoli | $0.75 |
others
coffee | $2.50 |
cold brew | $4.00 |
americano | $4.00 |
cappuccino | $4.00 |
cortado | $4.20 |
espresso | $3.50 |
latte | $5.00 |
macchiato | $4.00 |
la colombe & balthazar | - |
DISCLAIMER: The information provided may not reflect the most recent changes. Please contact the restaurant directly for the latest menu and pricing details. Listings on menusnearme.co do not imply any affiliation or endorsement between the listed restaurant.
Amenities and More
Bar
Vegan options
Chef's table
Parking available
Good for groups
Location and Hours
Discover Option Near Me
Top Restaurants
Amenities and More
Bar
Vegan options
Chef's table
Parking available
Good for groups
Location and Hours
Discover Option Near Me
$20 - 30
$20 - 30
$20–30
Top Restaurants
$10–20
$20 - 30