O'Toole's Way
Popular Dishes
Salsa rosa - arugula - charred lime
$30.00
Guinness battered cod - crushed peas - tartar - salt and vinegar
$30.00
Old bay mayo - buttered brioche
$32.00
14oz ny strip - grilled, sliced - crostini - thumbit sauce
$48.00
Goat cheese - arugula - hot honey
$22.00
Menu for O'Toole's Way
large plates
fillet of salmonsalsa rosa - arugula - charred lime | $30.00 |
proper fish and chipsguinness battered cod - crushed peas - tartar - salt and vinegar | $30.00 |
whole grilled branzino“head to tail” confit fennel - black olive dressing | $38.00 |
mussels and friesirish cider - garlic - cream - lemon - parsley | $28.00 |
charred cauliflower steakcauliflower and quinoa cous cous - spinach and cherry tomato - nigella seeds | $26.00 |
squash ravioliricotta - toasted hazelnuts - burnt butter - crispy sage | $24.00 |
brick chickenbuttermilk caesar slaw - charred lemon - fries | $28.00 |
short rib cottage piecolcannon - irish cheddar | $30.00 |
berkshire pork chopcharred carrots - carrot top chimichurri - apple cider and bourbon reduction | $32.00 |
steak frites14oz prime ny strip - espresso rub - watercress - truffle butter - roasted garlic - fries | $48.00 |
bar pies
prosciuttogoat cheese - arugula - hot honey | $22.00 |
garden squashmozzarella - pumpkin seed pesto - parmesan | $20.00 |
margheritatomato - mozzarella - basil | $18.00 |
sandwiches and burgers
o'toole's burgeramerican - caramelized onions - burger sauce - b+b pickles - brioche bun | $24.00 |
"dangerous dave's" dublin dipshaved prime rib - irish cheddar - caramelized onions - horseradish - clabatta - "with its own gravy" | $28.00 |
chicken your choice of fried or grilledpickled fresno - hot honey slaw - remoulade - brioche bun | $22.00 |
lobster bltold bay mayo - buttered brioche | $32.00 |
small plates
red pepper hummusmarket vegetable crudités | $12.00 |
irish cheese plateirish cheddar - cashel blue - gubbeen - crackers - quince - fig - pear | $24.00 |
espresso rubbed chicken wingsbuffalo or bourbon bbq - blue cheese dressing - crudités | $14.00 |
devils on horsebackdates - goat cheese - bacon - port reduction | $12.00 |
irish nachoshouse chips - cheese sauce - bacon - pickled fresnos - sour cream - scallions | $15.00 |
miso baked oysters rockefeller | $16.00 |
table-side
steak tartareegg yolk - crostini | $26.00 |
soup and salads
sirloin steak on toast14oz ny strip - grilled, sliced - crostini - thumbit sauce | $48.00 |
farmhouse potato and leek soupserved with house-made soda bread | $12.00 |
traditional cobbbleu cheese - egg - avocado - bacon - mkt greens - red wine vinaigrette | $18.00 |
kale caesarcharred lime - parmesan - croutons - caesar dressing | $19.00 |
pub saladmarket vegetables - house dressing | $16.00 |
the high linequinoa - hummus - dried cranberry - broccoli - toasted almonds - carrot - maple dressing | $18.00 |
for the table
friesparmesan & truffle oil +2 dirty them +5 | $10.00 |
zucchinilemon - parmesan | $10.00 |
grilled asparagus | $15.00 |
colcannonirish mashed potatoes | $10.00 |
irish bread service
house chipsirish cheddar onion dip | $14.00 |
house-made soda breadwhipped marmite butter | $12.00 |
bottles and cans
amstel lightlight lager - netherlands 3.5% | $7.00 |
budweiserlager - st. louis, mo 5% | $7.00 |
bud lightlight lager - st. louis, mo 4.2% | $6.00 |
heinekenpale lager - netherlands 5% | $7.00 |
coronalager - mexico 4.6% | $7.00 |
coney island mermanipa - brooklyn 5.8% | $8.00 |
radebergerpilsner - germany 4.8% | $8.00 |
montauk easy riserbelgium white - ny 5% | $8.00 |
magnershard cider - ireland 4.5% | $8.00 |
nutrlvodka seltzer - seasonal flavors | $9.00 |
heineken 0.0non-alcoholic - netherlands .05% | $7.00 |
draught
guinnessstout - ireland 4.2% | $10.00 |
stella artoispilsner - belgium 4.8% | $9.00 |
sam adams seasonal | $9.00 |
blue point toastedlager - long island 5.5% | $9.00 |
modelopilsner - mexico 4.4% | $8.00 |
kona big wavegolden ale - hawaii 4.4% | $9.00 |
ebbs ipa no.7ipa - brooklyn 5.5% | $9.00 |
cigar city fancy papershazy ipa - florida 6.5% | $9.00 |
cocktails
volareprosecco / italicus rosolio di bergamotto / thyme infused vermouth / castelvetrano olives | $16.00 |
wet the teagrey goose vodka / yuzu / honey / lavender / lemon / blue cornflower | $18.00 |
bootleggerghost tequila / cazadores silver / hibiscus / rockey's botanical / lime / rose salt | $18.00 |
rising moonbacardi cuatro rum / vanilla-cinnamon syrup / pineapple / lime / star anise / nutmeg | $18.00 |
west side hooligangreat jones bourbon / guinness syrup / orange + chocolate bitters | $17.00 |
ny state of mindhudson bourbon / sage infused sweet vermouth / pomegranate / bitters | $18.00 |
proper sipgin lane 1751 / apple cider / q tonic / orange | $17.00 |
classics
manhattanmakers mark bourbon | $18.00 |
negronigin lane victoria pink | $16.00 |
vesperhendricks gin - tito's vodka - lillet | $18.00 |
pimms cupcucumber - mint - lemon - ginger beer | $15.00 |
the o'toole's way
irish coffeebushmill's irish whiskey | $15.00 |
espresso martiniketel one vodka - cold brew - mr. black coffee liqueur | $18.00 |
irish espresso martinijameson cold brew whiskey - mr. black coffee liqueur - cold brew | $18.00 |
old fashioneds
angels envycherry bitters - demerara - smoked | - |
patron reposadocinnamon and grapefruit bitters - agave | - |
bulleit ryeorange and angostura bitters - demerara | - |
hudson bright lights | big city bourbonorange and peach bitters - demerara | - |
lie-bations
st agrestis phony negroni | $14.00 |
golden harvestlyre's agave blanco spirit - pear - lemon - rosemary - club soda | $15.00 |
sober water
cucumber-mint-lime soda | - |
pineapple-ginger fizz | - |
pomegranate lemonade | - |
others
spiced hot apple ciderbacardi spiced rum - apple cider - citrus | $16.00 |
DISCLAIMER: The information provided may not reflect the most recent changes. Please contact the restaurant directly for the latest menu and pricing details. Listings on menusnearme.co do not imply any affiliation or endorsement between the listed restaurant.
Amenities and More
Takeout available
Late-night dining
Chef's table
Buffet
Credit card
Location and Hours
Discover Option Near Me
Top Restaurants
Amenities and More
Takeout available
Late-night dining
Chef's table
Buffet
Credit card
Location and Hours
Discover Option Near Me
$30–50
$100+
$30 - 50
$100+
Top Restaurants
$30–50