Muscarella's Pizzeria Lancaster NY
Popular Dishes
Sahlen's ham, chicken fingers & swiss cheese
$9.99
Sweet peppers & onions or hp & onions
$7.99
(bbq dip included) grilled steak / cheese, french fries
$7.99
Bleu cheese $1.00
$5.99
Includes lettuce, tomato, onions, ham, capicola, salami, hot peppers, black olives, green olives, mozzarella cheese & pepperoni
$8.99
Menu for Muscarella's Pizzeria Lancaster NY
submarines
assorted | $6.99 |
b.l.t. | $6.99 |
bacon cheeseburger | $8.99 |
capicola (bison) | $5.99 |
cheese (baked) | $3.99 |
cheeseburger | $7.99 |
chicken cordon bleusahlen's ham, chicken fingers & swiss cheese | $9.99 |
chicken finger | $8.99 |
fish sub (only during lent) | $6.99 |
grilled chicken | $6.99 |
grilled chicken supremesweet peppers & onions or hp & onions | $7.99 |
ham (sahlen's) | $5.99 |
hamburger | $6.99 |
italian sausage patty | $7.99 |
muscarella meltmelted cheddar, bbq chicken fingers, bacon, bleu cheese, lettuce, tomatoes | $9.99 |
pizzacheese plus 1 topping | $4.99 |
royal (sausage & capicola) | $7.99 |
salami (hard) | $5.99 |
steak (chopped sirloin) | $7.99 |
steak supremesweet peppers & onions or hp & onions | $8.99 |
steak & sausage | $9.99 |
stingerlettuce & tomatoes on request choice of condiments, includes chopped sirloin steak, chicken fingers and your choice of flavor and bacon. | $9.99 |
tuna | $4.99 |
turkey (latinas #1 choice) | $5.99 |
turkey bacon club | $6.99 |
vegetarianincludes black olives, green olives, hot peppers and cheese on request | $3.99 |
"vincenzo" special assorted cold cuts & italian sausage | $8.99 |
sicilian pizza sub | $3.99 |
side orders
frankie fries(bbq dip included) grilled steak / cheese, french fries | $7.99 |
french fries | $4.99 |
bbq french friesbleu cheese $1.00 | $5.99 |
loaded friesincludes bacon and cheddar | $6.99 |
loaded waffle ff | $7.99 |
sweet potato fries w/honey | $5.99 |
waffle fries | $5.99 |
onion rings | $5.99 |
fried cauliflower(15) includes bleu cheese | $6.50 |
fried mushrooms(15) includes bleu cheese | $6.50 |
fried zucchini(15) includes marinara sauce | $6.50 |
jalapeno poppers(5) includes bleu cheese | $5.99 |
fried dough sticks | $6.50 |
loaded garlic breadspinach, onions, tomatoes and mozzarella cheese | $4.99 |
mozzarella sticks(5) includes marinara sauce | $6.99 |
pizza logs(5) includes marinara sauce | $10.99 |
cajun onion ringsincludes bleu cheese | $6.99 |
cajun french friesincludes bleu cheese | $6.50 |
garlic breadno cheese | $2.99 |
garlic bread w/ cheese & tomato | $4.49 |
breadsticks | $4.49 |
tator tots | $5.99 |
loaded tator tots | $7.99 |
salads
antipastoincludes lettuce, tomato, onions, ham, capicola, salami, hot peppers, black olives, green olives, mozzarella cheese & pepperoni | $8.99 |
julienneincludes lettuce, tomato, onions, turkey, ham & provolone cheese | $6.99 |
tunaincludes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese | $6.99 |
grilled chickenincludes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone | $9.99 |
steakincludes lettuce, tomato, fried onions, mushrooms & cheddar | $9.99 |
caesar salad | $6.99 |
grilled steak caesar | $11.99 |
grilled chicken caesar | $11.99 |
chefsincludes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & provolone cheese | $4.99 |
chicken finger saladincludes lettuce, tomato, onions, black olives & cheddar, | $11.99 |
lunch specials
2 slices cheese & pepperoni pizza | $8.00 |
5 chicken wings + bag of chips | $7.00 |
half cold sub + bag of chips | $6.00 |
half hot sub + bag of chipsadd $1.00 for hot subs | $7.00 |
6 boneless wings + french fries | $6.00 |
any wrap + bag of chips | $6.00 |
small chef salad + half garlic bread | $6.00 |
mini calzone cheese + 1 topping | $6.00 |
cheeseburger or hamburger sandwich + french fries | $6.00 |
3 chicken fingers + french friesadd $1.00 | $8.00 |
mini breadsticks with cheese | $6.00 |
chicken wings
hot | medium | mild | suicidal | char-d bbq wings | bbq | honey mustard | italian | cajun-style | suicidal sauce & bbq | sweet thai chile | teriyaki/sesame(served with honey dip sauce) | $16.99 |
pizza
colossal pizza 20" cheese | $6.00 |
sheet (2 lg. pizzas) 24/32 sq. cheese | $6.00 |
large 16" pizza cheese | $4.00 |
small 12" pizza cheese | $3.00 |
personal 9" pizza cheese | $2.00 |
slice of cheese & pepperoni | $4.00 |
slice of specialty pizza | $5.00 |
sandwiches
hamburger | $4.99 |
cheeseburger | $5.99 |
"the super shroom"includes hamburger, fried onions, fried mushrooms, melted swiss cheese | $6.99 |
italian sausage | $4.99 |
bacon cheeseburger | $6.99 |
"italian stallion"includes italian sausage patty, onions, fried onions & sweet peppers w/melted provolone cheese | $6.99 |
chicken fingers
chicken fingersincludes french fries, bleu cheese & carrots & any style | $14.50 |
boneless wings
single boneless wings | $11.99 |
double boneless wings | $20.99 |
triple boneless wings | $28.99 |
bucket boneless wings | $42.99 |
wraps
grilled steak | $6.99 |
grilled steak caesar | $7.49 |
grilled chicken | $6.99 |
grilled chicken caesar | $7.49 |
supreme chicken | $7.49 |
or steak | $7.49 |
chicken finger | $6.99 |
turkey | $5.99 |
assorted | $6.49 |
tuna | $5.99 |
vegetarian | $4.99 |
steak | $6.99 |
ham | $5.99 |
antipasto | $6.99 |
daily specials
small pizza (c + 1 topping) & 10 wings | $28.99 |
large pizza (c + 1 topping) & 10 chicken fingers | $42.99 |
large pizza (c + 1 topping) & 20 wings | $49.99 |
colossal pizza (c + 1 topping) & 30 wings | $59.99 |
sheet pizza (c + 1 topping) & 50 wings | $85.99 |
parm subs
steak parm | $7.99 |
eggplant | $6.99 |
meatball | $6.99 |
italian sausage | $7.99 |
chicken finger | $8.99 |
calzones
create your ownincludes cheese | $9.95 |
specialty pizza calzone | $14.95 |
boneless wings specials
small pizza (c + 1 topping) & 10 boneless wings | $21.99 |
large pizza (c + 1 topping) & 20 boneless wings | $36.99 |
colossal pizza (c + 1 topping) & 30 boneless wings | $50.99 |
sheet pizza (c + 1 topping) & 50 boneless wings | $64.99 |
beverages
cherry coke | $2.50 |
coke | $2.50 |
diet coke | $2.50 |
sprite | $2.50 |
logan berry | $2.50 |
dasani | $2.50 |
orange | $2.50 |
root beer | $2.50 |
ginger ale | $2.50 |
lemonade | $2.50 |
pink lemonade | $2.50 |
water | $2.50 |
specialty pizza
chicken finger pizzableu cheese, mild, medium, bbq or hot sauce, chicken fingers, 2 cheeses, (lettuce & tomato optional) | $11.99 |
broccoli & cheddar pizzaolive oil, 2 cheeses & broccoli florets | $9.99 |
steak pizzamade either red (with sauce) or white (with oil & garlic), cheddar & mozzarella cheeses, onions & hot or sweet peppers | $11.99 |
sicilian pizzamade with 100% olive oil, fresh tomatoes, onions, asiago cheese & spices. anchovies on request | $9.99 |
the worksincludes cheese, pepperoni, mushrooms, sausage, onions, sweet peppers, hot peppers, black olives & green olives | $11.99 |
the "hog"includes cheese, pepperoni, bacon, sausage & ham | $11.99 |
the hawaiianincludes cheese, ham & pineapple | $9.99 |
the romanoincludes romano cheese, sautéed onions & hot peppers | $10.99 |
fish fry
12 oz icelandic haddock | $15.99 |
DISCLAIMER: The information provided may not reflect the most recent changes. Please contact the restaurant directly for the latest menu and pricing details. Listings on menusnearme.co do not imply any affiliation or endorsement between the listed restaurant.
Amenities and More
Chef's table
Private dining
Good for groups
Dinning option
Buffet
Location and Hours
Discover Option Near Me
Top Restaurants
Amenities and More
Chef's table
Private dining
Good for groups
Dinning option
Buffet
Location and Hours
Discover Option Near Me
$10–20
$10–20
$10–20
Top Restaurants
$10–20